[Close Window]


My Second Letter to BMW NA


September 4, 2002


Hans G. Duenzl
Vice President, Aftersales and Engineering
BMW of North America, LLC
PO Box 1227
Westwood, NJ 07675-1227


Dear Mr. Duenzl,

Honesty, Accountability, Responsiveness � these are the attributes and the responsibilities of a premium automobile manufacturer.

As much as BMW of North America, LLC, is concerned with running a viable business, we, your customers, demand we be treated fairly. We are listening carefully to BMW NA . . . and we don't like what we're hearing.

We do not know if you are in receipt of our letter, dated August 17, sent to BMW of North America (copy enclosed). In that letter, we expressed our concerns regarding the rash of catastrophic engine failures plaguing M3 cars produced in late 2001 and early 2002, such as our own. It was our belief that such a letter, arriving from the purchasers of a car costing nearly $60,000, would elicit a prompt and personal response from your company.

A few weeks after we mailed the above-mentioned letter, we received your August letter to BMW E46 M3 owners. We found it extremely infuriating and unnerving. That the focus of this two-page letter should be entirely on proper use and maintenance of the car is insulting, as it suggests that we may either inadvertently or intentionally mistreat our vehicle, which we assure you we do not. Such maintenance information is available in the owner's manual and, we would expect, from our BMW service department. We do not know just how you view your customer base, but we are certain that the majority of owners of these expensive vehicles are not complete idiots.

Please do not patronize us or attempt to avoid the issue.

We believe that focusing on obvious maintenance guidelines is an effort by BMW NA to lay the groundwork for blaming owners for any future engine failures that may occur, rather than to take responsibility for what is surely a manufacturing or assembly defect. We all know that such a high failure rate is atypical and extremely serious. The fact is, regardless of whether our vehicle's engine fails or not, there is now so much concern over the reliability of these vehicles that the resale value has likely plummeted, along with our confidence in BMW NA. The potential for serious injury or loss of life casts a pall over our ownership experience.

We do not assume that BMW NA or BMW AG have had enough time to complete the necessary research into the engine failure issue. We do not presume to know what, exactly, is the best course of action for the company to take. What we do know is that it is time for your company to contact us personally, in writing, to make it clear that you are aware of the issue, you are working on a remedy to the mechanical problem, and you will take good care of us, your heretofore loyal customers.

Gentlemen, it is time to stand behind your customers!

Please do not misunderstand us. This is no case of buyer's remorse. We derive great satisfaction from owning and driving such a fine automobile as the new M3. It is for this reason and for our significant financial investment that we are so concerned about the continued reliability of our car. We hope that, in years to come, we can still take that proud walk to the garage, fire-up the M3, and enjoy our time driving it.

You can reach us at the address above should you have any questions or further information for us.

We look forward to your Honesty, Accountability, and Responsiveness.


Sincerely,


[signed]

Cc: Step Jones, General Manager, Beverly Hills BMW
Cc: Fernando Altonaga, Service Manager, Beverly Hills BMW



[Close Window]



Visit 755 since September 4, 2002.