[Close Window]
My Response to the AutoWeek Article
December 4, 2002
AutoWeek (awletter@crain.com)
Dear AutoWeek,
Thank you for covering this story. Without the media, many owners believe we would have no recourse other than a lawsuit in seeking a resolution to the problem with the BMW M3's S54 engine. I feel compelled to point out a few statements that may either be misleading or erroneous.
Most importantly, the failures are certainly not "isolated to models built between November and December '01." Though the bulk of failures have been in vehicles produced between October and December of 2001, there are significant failures in cars produced in March and April of 2001 and those produced in January and February of 2002. This is based on failures reported on Roadfly and archived on Jason's Archive site (http://members.roadfly.org/jason/m3engines.htm). For BMW to state that it's "'probably under 100' cases in the United States" is outrageous, considering the fact that they, an ISO-certified company, must know exactly how many failures there have been in the US and worldwide, and that their number is quite low, with over 112 failures reported on Roadfly alone. A more likely number is in excess of 300.
I must also take issue with the emphasis on track-related events. The vast majority of these failures occurred on public roads, in vehicles that seldom or never saw any track use. Frankly, I'd prefer a failure to occur in the controlled environment of a driver's education event, rather than on a busy freeway.
Any mention of owner abuse is frustrating, as it is beside the point. Sure, it's great that BMW replaced an engine that was likely abused, but that has no bearing (no pun intended) on this issue. This is clearly not a maintenance or warm-up issue. There is a direct correlation between the dates that BMW changed their main engine bearing specifications and the failure rates of the S54 engine. I've attached an image of the Technical Service Bulletin (TSB) from November, detailing the change.
We are not expecting to "push BMW's benevolence," nor are most owners willing to depend on that benevolence. BMW should not insist on handling this "on a case-by-case basis," as the risk of leaving these potentially dangerous engines in the field is too great. The time has come for us to have a fair, complete, concrete resolution. BMW must demonstrate that they value their customers' safety over all else.
Sincerely yours,
John Turkel
/failures
Cc: John D. Stoll, AutoWeek
[Close Window]
Visit 645 since October 19, 2002.